Introduction to MauiPeterBMovieReviews.blogspot.com
Click this link to read:
To find films, actors, directors, etc., use 'Search This Blog' omitting accents (à ç é ô ü). Ratings average IMDb, Metacritic and Rotten Tomatoes: ***** Excellent (81+); **** Very Good (61-80); *** Average (40-60); ** Fair (20-39); * Poor (19-). CONTACT ME: mauipeterb at hotmail dot com
A film review by James Berardinelli for ReelViews.net on Nov. 1, 2024.
For a movie like Here, which eschews the norms of narrative filmmaking in favor of something experimental, the first question to ask is whether the story, stripped bare of the director’s approach, is worth telling. The second question is whether the decision to approach the movie in a nontraditional fashion adds anything to the production. Providing an answer to the first question is more difficult than the second. At its heart, Here is a fairly straightforward melodrama and its strength comes from the accessibility and relatability of the characters and their circumstances. Most of us will have known (or been) these people at various times during our lives. Certain moments have a poignancy that comes from the connections formed between on-screen characters and those watching in the audience. But the biggest problems with Here are the extraneous plot elements that bog down the basic story (in order to advance a theme about impermanence), the ill-advised chronological dysfunction favored by director Robert Zemeckis, and the awkward, distracting use of frames to provide transitions. Although these things don’t destroy the film, they reduce its overall impact and emotional resonance. It’s difficult (if not impossible) to become immersed in a movie when the director is constantly reminding us that it is a movie.
Berardinelli's full film review (2.5 stars out of 4)
Labels: drama, Tom Hanks
IMDb 63/100
MetaScore (critics=39, viewers=48)
RottenTomatoes Averages (critics=44, viewers=68)