A film review by Sherin Nicole for RogerEbert.com on June 19, 2026.
Grief and love can make us vulnerable; they can also open us up to new
possibilities. That’s the central theme of this Black List breakout
screenplay, now a Netflix rom-com. Starring Zoey Deutch as Jill and Nick Robinson as Wes, Voicemails for Isabelle follows Jill, an aspiring pastry
chef, in the aftermath of losing the love of her life - her little sister.
Struggling to cope, she continues to leave Izzy voicemail messages. It’s
super sweet and very You’ve Got Mail, because Jill has no idea Wes, an
Austin real estate agent, is now receiving her extremely personal audio
diaries. He’s listening in on her deep dive into the horrors of dating
in San Francisco, and he’s all in.
Written and directed by Leah McKendrick, Voicemails for Isabelle is
two love stories in one. The first is the tale of two sisters. Jill is a
fully self-actualized ‘live, laugh, love’ kind of girl. Izzy
is chronically ill with cystic fibrosis and spends most of her time
between home and the hospital. That’s why Jill is living life x 2,
experiencing the biggest feelings in the most colorful ways so Izzy can
experience them too. When Izzy dies, Jill doesn’t slow down, but she
struggles to find a connection. After a life of dating disappointments
that started on the playground, the only person she can talk to is her
sister. She keeps replaying Izzy’s messages and responding with new
ones. As the movie points out, it’s her attempt to heal, and that’s
pretty healthy.
That’s where the second love story begins. Wes is a romantically
untouchable high-dollar realtor who spends his time with his cousin Andy
(Harry Shum Jr.) and Andy’s fiancée, Breeda (McKendrick). He’s the kind
of guy who’ll utilize any edge to attain his goals - even the ethically
questionable ones. It never occurs to Wes to stop listening to Jill’s
messages or to avoid using them in getting to know her when they
meet-cute. And although we cringe at his methods, the entire thing is so
adorable we’re mostly willing to forgive him - if Jill does - and he learns
his lesson.
This is a rom-com with many themes and an acute (sometimes pink) eye for
current dating woes, social media pitfalls, and misogyny. Giving us
classic rom-com aesthetics, McKendrick balances this story line whirlwind
without it becoming overblown. A big part of that is the writing and
cast. Deutch is fierce, but also awkward and perceptive, like Jill.
Robinson’s Wes is a sweetheart, but he’s clueless with wobbly
boundaries. Adding to the charm are Nick Offerman - when is he not the
secret sauce - and the character-acting chameleon Lukas Gage. They’re a
pair of posers/chefs who despise women, allowing the movie to cut deep
into the chauvinism found in the workplace. That works well alongside
the uncertainty that reigns during times of mourning. Shum Jr. and
McKendrick are the bestest couple, seeing and saying what’s right when
Wes doesn’t. If you don’t end up quoting them, that’s on you, bro.
This is a true rom-com; we know where it’s going, but the good times are
in the roadmap to getting there. The banter sparkles with the kind of
inside jokes found in friend groups (and the writing lets us in). The
grand gestures are unexpected, while the couple’s bonding moments are
real, ridiculous, or both. Voicemails for Isabelle has a high
emotional IQ, a romantic journey you’ll want to follow, and a real sense
of the lunacy that makes life hilarious - even when we’re hurting.
McKendrick packs a lot of ingredients into this big love burrito, and
just like the best taco trucks, it works ‘cause it meets us where we’re
at with the goods. (Nicole's rating: 3 stars out of 4)
Labels: comedy, drama, romance, tragedy
IMDb 74/100
MetaCritic (critics=62, viewers=59)
RottenTomatoes Averages (critics=67, viewers=90)
Netflix
Sherin Nicole's original review (3 stars out of 4)


The film’s second half is more grounded. The rags-to-riches
arc peters out. There are physical challenges (she’s involved in a crippling
accident, he has a heart condition) and they must cope with the public’s fickle
fascination with tribute acts. And, with most of Diamond’s best-known songs
having been showcased during the first hour, the soundtrack becomes less
pop-heavy - at least until the rousing finale. Ultimately, this structure allows
Brewer to deliver a full serving of Diamond nostalgia without strip-mining the
singer’s life story. It’s a far better approach and makes Song Sung Blue
more accessible than either A Complete Unknown or Deliver Me from Nowhere, two recent examples of biographical overreach.
Brewer’s source material for the screenplay is a
little-known 2008 documentary by Philadelphia-based filmmaker Greg Kohs, who
followed the duo on and off for about eight years, assembling footage. Kohs’ Song
Sung Blue did well on the film-festival circuit (it debuted at Slamdance)
but never gained much traction beyond that, in part because, despite their
renown in the Milwaukee area, Lightning & Thunder’s appeal never extended
much beyond regional interest. Still, when Brewer watched it, he recognized
the potential. 









