Friday, March 27, 2009
The Philadelphia Story (1940) [NR] *****
A film review by fourstarfilmfan.wordpress.com on December 26, 2015.
If there ever was a benchmark for the sophisticated, high-society brand of comedy, The Philadelphia Story is most certainly it. It’s less screwball because instead of Howard Hawks, George Cukor takes the helm and injects the film with his more refined sensibilities. It’s still very much hilarious and impeccably witty, but it’s not quite as scatterbrained as it could have been. Once more you have the iconic pairing of Cary Grant with Katharine Hepburn. Previously they had been in two other Cukor pictures (Sylvia Scarlett and Holiday) and of course Hawks’ romp Bringing up Baby. However, this time they’re joined by another cinematic titan in James Stewart and it proves to be a wonderful battle for command of the screen. The story ends up being a wonderful clash of classes and culture that also manages to illuminate a few bits and pieces of truth.
C.K. Dexter Haven (Cary Grant) had it out rather acrimoniously with his wife Tracy Lord (Katharine Hepburn) and now two years down the line she is set to marry someone else. She couldn’t be happier to be rid of him and all his faults. Her new husband is a real man of the people, the wooden George Kittredge (John Howard), and he got his money doing an honest day’s work. In other words, he’s everything Dexter (Grant) isn’t when it comes to class and manners, but he’s also quite different than Tracy. But she doesn’t seem to mind. She’s on cloud nine to be rid of Dexter.
Although Dexter does take a back seat at times, it’s only so he can manipulate and connive in the background, because he most certainly has an agenda. It’s great fun to watch. First he brings in the folks from Spy magazine to do a full spread on the big wedding. There’s belligerent journalist Macaulay Mike Connor (James Stewart) scoffing at all the opulence around him and then photographer Ms. Elizabeth Imbrie (Ruth Hussey), who has something complicated going on with her colleague. They’re all here because the editor of Spy has a nice juicy piece expose on Tracy’s father, and so Dexter advises her to go along with it. She suspects her old spouse has something to do with it, and it’s true, he didn’t put up much a protest when it came to taking part. However, Tracy’s not ready to let him ruin what she’s got going. She and her younger sister, the crack-up Dinah (Virginia Weidler), put on a good show of upper class snobbery to utterly bewilder their guests.
The funny thing is that while Tracy detests Dexter with the vehemence of the plague, her mother and sister quickly welcome him back into their home with open arms. After all, what kind of trouble could he cause a couple days before the wedding, and Dinah is always game for a little chaos. She and Dexter have a mutual affection for each other. They’re both serial troublemakers.
After the surprise of Dexter wears off, the next person Tracy clashes horns with is the brusque newsman Connor, who is as turned off by her as she is annoyed by him. As she sees it, he’s invading her house as part of the paper’s plan to make her life miserable and steal away all her privacy. For Connor, Tracy’s a stuck up brat, who has had everything served to her on a silver platter in the west drawing room. He thumbs his nose at the whole set-up. But a chance encounter at the library no less, opens up a different side to these characters. Connor is actually an accomplished novelist, far more skilled than his lousy journalistic pursuits would suggest. He learns just how perfectly imperfect she is.
It’s at a party the night before the big day that things get particular interesting. A lot happens when you fill people up with a little champagne, some wine, and some early morning gaiety. Tracy is absolutely swimming in exuberance partially thanks to alcohol, partially because of the dancing, and maybe in expectation of tomorrow’s high. But when things come a little loose around the edges, things happen that you regret. As it turns out, Tracy doesn’t remember quite what happened that night, but Dinah saw all the good parts from her balcony. It involved a drunken Connor taking a jaunt to Dexter’s home at a god-forsaken hour, followed by Ms. Imbrie with an inebriated Tracy in tow. What this sets up is a wonderful little sequence where a hiccupping Connor helps Dexter orchestrate a plot to get back at Spy magazine editor Sidney Kidd. Then, Connor gets to spend the wee hours of the morning rambling on and on. It’s innocent enough, but quite the evening no less. It makes Kittredge quite distraught finding his bride to be in the arms of a man who is singing Somewhere over the Rainbow. And of course with such an unfortunate moment so close to the wedding it looks like things will be called off. But Kittredge is willing to make amends. It’s Tracy who realizes she has to break things off, because ironically this man is too good for her.
It looks like Dexter has won, but in a split second Connor is proposing marriage and ready to tie the knot with Tracy to save the wedding. Once again Tracy makes a sagacious decision (which is surprising given her earlier condition). Hangovers on your wedding day are not usually a good thing. In this moment everything falls back into place as it should and as we want it to. These are characters that we grow to care about, despite their misgivings and class differences.
When reading up on this film I was astounded to hear that the film supposedly had no outtakes. Everything we see was as it was when it was first shot and that has to be a testament to the strength of these actors and maybe a little luck. It’s true that the film sometimes enters territory that feels unscripted and loose. That’s when it really gets fun. Stewart and Hepburn. Grant throwing a quick retort here and there. Imagine, this could have been a vehicle for Hepburn paired with Clark Gable and Spencer Tracy. I’m sure that would have been great, but the whole dynamic would have been very different.
So who is the winner in this film? Cary Grant as Dexter? Katharine Hepburn as Tracy? James Stewart as Connor? The Philadelphia Story is a real winner for the audience. What more could you want in terms of high-brow comedy bursting with legendary star power? [Reviewer’s rating: ***** out of 5 stars]
Academy Awards: James Stewart, Best Leading Actor; Donald Ogden Stewart, Best Writing, Screenplay
Academy Awards Nominations: Joseph L. Mankiewicz, Best Picture; Katharine Hepburn, Best Leading Actress; Ruth Hussey, Best Supporting Actress; George Cukor, Best Director.
Labels: comedy, romance